When it comes to body jewellery, choosing the right material is essential. Two of the most popular materials are titanium and gold. Both offer excellent biocompatibility and aesthetics, but they differ in terms of durability, cost, and design possibilities. This guide will break down the differences between titanium and 14ct or 18ct gold for body jewellery and explore the design restrictions that come with each material. So lets see Titanium vs Gold: Which Material is Best for Body Jewellery?
What is Titanium?
Titanium is a lightweight, durable, and hypoallergenic metal. It's often used in body piercing jewellery because of its strength, corrosion resistance, and affordability. Specifically, the industry standard is 6AL4V ASTM F-Â136 the most common grade used for piercing jewellery. Industrial strength have also introduced newer more biocompatible material – 6AL7NB ASTM F1295 implant grade titanium. It's also implant-grade, meaning it is safe to wear long-term.
What is 14ct & 18ct Gold?
Gold used in body jewellery is typically available in 14ct, 18ct, or higher. This type of gold contains a mixture of gold and other alloy metals like copper, silver, and palladium to increase its strength. 14ct gold is often preferred because it strikes a balance between purity and durability. It's also available in various shades, including yellow, white, and rose gold, offering versatility in style.
Key Differences Between Titanium and 14ct & 18ct Gold in Body Jewellery
1. Hypoallergenic Properties
Titanium: Extremely hypoallergenic and safe for those with metal sensitivities. It's an excellent choice for fresh piercings.
14ct &18ct Gold: 14ct & 18ct gold is generally safe, but lower carat gold can cause allergic reactions due to the alloy metals present. It's advisable to stick to higher purity gold (14ct or more) to reduce the risk of irritation. 9ct is defiantly not appropriate for use as body jewellery but unfortunately is widely used by high street shops and in "piercing guns/ systems"
2. Weight
Titanium: Lightweight, making it comfortable for piercings that need minimal pressure, like ear cartilage or nose piercings.
14ct & 18ct Gold: Heavier than titanium, which can be beneficial for certain jewellery pieces but may cause discomfort in delicate piercings over time if large attachments are worn.
3. Durability
Titanium: Known for its extreme durability and scratch resistance, making it ideal for long-term wear.
14ct & 18ct Gold: While gold is more prone to scratches, it's still durable enough for everyday use, especially in14ct or higher solid pieces.
4. Cost
Titanium: Affordable compared to gold, making it accessible for those looking for high-quality but cost-effective jewellery.
14ct & 18ct Gold: More expensive, with the price increasing alongside the carat value and weight. 18ct gold or higher will cost significantly more but offer higher prestige and a richer color.
5. Appearance
Titanium: Comes in various anodized colors, allowing for versatile design options. It can be polished to a high shine or left with a matte finish but this is not recommended or used for body jewellery.
14ct & 18ct Gold: Offers a luxurious and timeless look, with options for yellow, white, or rose gold in varying shades depending on the composition. The color won't fade over time, adding to its appeal.
Design Restrictions for Titanium vs. 14ct & 18ct Gold
1. Titanium Design Restrictions
Complex Designs: Titanium is difficult to cast, which limits its use in highly intricate designs. Most titanium jewellery is made through machining and anodizing techniques to change the colour, meaning it may not accommodate complex details.
Anodizing Limitations: While anodizing titanium allows for a wide range of colors, it is not suitable for Black and precise coloring patterns can be very difficult to achieve.
Minimal Use of Gemstones: Although gemstones can be set into titanium, its hardness makes the process more challenging. It’s more common to see titanium used in simpler, gem designs.
2. 14ct &18ct Gold Design Restrictions
Softness: Gold is a softer metal, so intricate designs are easier to create. This means you often get more decorative designs on the settings and pieces themselves in general.
Weight Considerations: Because gold is heavier, larger designs can put more pressure on piercings, which may cause discomfort unless balanced properly with the appropriate post length and disk after downsizing.
Cost of Custom Designs: The price of custom gold jewellery can be significantly higher due to both the material cost and the labor involved in detailed goldsmithing work. There are goldsmiths out there such as Danila Tarcinale who create truly beautiful bespoke work.
Which Material Should You Choose for Your Body Jewellery?
Choosing between titanium and 14ct & 18ct gold depends on your personal needs, lifestyle, and aesthetic preferences. Here's a quick breakdown:
Choose Titanium if you’re looking for:
Hypoallergenic properties and minimal risk of irritation
Affordability
Lightweight comfort
Durability for long-term wear
A wide range of anodized color options
Choose 14ct or 18ct Gold if you want:
A luxurious, timeless look
The option for yellow, white, or rose gold
A premium feeling piece
A higher status symbol
The ability to incorporate intricate designs and gemstones
Final Thoughts
Both titanium and 14ct & 18ct gold have their advantages, and the choice largely depends on what you're looking for in terms of comfort, cost, and aesthetics. Titanium offers affordability, hypoallergenic properties, and durability, while 14ct & 18ct gold provides elegance, luxury, and design versatility. Regardless of which material you choose, both are excellent choices for high-quality body jewellery that will last.
FAQs About Titanium and 14ct & 18ct Gold in Body Jewellery
1. Is titanium safe for all piercings?
Yes, but not all Titanium is implant-grade. Please make sure your chosen studio is using suppliers from the approved APP jewellerey verification program (linked here) Even healed piercings should have industry standard jewellery in them.
2. Does 14ct & 18ct gold tarnish over time?
No, 14ct & 18ct gold does not tarnish, though it may develop a patina or minor scratches with regular wear.
3. Can I wear titanium or gold body jewellery during an MRI?**
Titanium is generally MRI-safe, but gold may not be depending on the alloys used. Always consult your healthcare provider before an MRI.
Optimize Your Piercing with the Right Material
Whether you opt for titanium or 14ct &18ct gold, both materials are an excellent choice for your piercing journey. If you're ready to choose your next body jewellery piece, browse our collection of premium titanium and gold jewellery now!
Comments